|
JCCD-3041:
Jazz Nocturne 4 - Bocage & Bechet in Boston
|
|
|
Personnel:
Peter Bocage [tp], Sidney Bechet [ssx], Ray Parker [pn],
Pops Foster [sbs], George Thompson [dm] |
|
|
Reviews for:
JCCD-3041: Jazz Nocturne 4 - Bocage & Bechet in Boston Jazz Journal International International - British The first tracks here are from the evening performance following on from
the rehearsal which featured on Volume 1. Sad to say, Bunk's playing here
is well below his standard of the afternoon, when he sounded interested
and involved. Here, impeded by a balance which, admittedly, does him no
favours (or maybe he was blowing away from the microphone deliberately!),
for much of the time he provides little more than a restrained obbligato
to Bechet's exuberant soprano saxophone playing. Bunk is more prominent,
and better balanced, on the second session, but his tone is rather sour
and his phrasing approximate and often hesitant while Bechet, once more,
carries all before him. To be fair, the trumpeter often sounds genuinely
perplexed about how to fit in with his partner, who does very little to
accommodate him. It isclearthatthe whole enterprise was ill-fated from
the start because of the two old friends' mutually abrasive personalities.
The final two titles are made more interesting by the replacement of the
rather uninspired Parker and Thompson by the expert stride piano of Hank
Duncan and the resonant drumming of Freddie Moore, experienced musicians
both and more in keeping with the splendid work of Pops Foster who virtually
kept the rhythm going all by himself on the other sessions. The two titles
recorded from that evening comprise Bunk's valediction to Boston, and
it sounds as if he couldn't wait to get away from the place. Cadence Magazine - U. S. A. Big Bill Bissonnette on his Jazz Crusade label has released five CDs
ihal are drawn from the Bunk Johnson and Peter Bocage appearances but
not the superior Johnny Windhurst dates. (4) (subtitled Jazz Nocturne
3) features the Bunk version of the band and is drawn from the broadcasts
of Apr. 3 (St. Louis Blues/ Ain't Misbehavin'/ 1 Never Knew/ Never No
Lament/ Darktown Strutters Ball/ Basin Street Blues/ Wang Wang Blues),
Apr. 5 (Willie The Weeper/ 1 Found A New Baby/ 12th Street Rag/ Embraceable
You/The World Is Waiting For the Sunrise/ Memphis Blues/ 1 Ain'l Got Notody)
and Apr. 7 (Sleepy Time Down South/ 1 Know That You Know). The Apr. 7
session has pianist Hank Duncan and drummer Freddie Moore filling in for
Parker and Thompson. Bechet is in typically wondrous form throughout while
Johnson is good in spots, weak in others. Although Bechet tries to lei
Bunk be the lead voice, any time The trumpeter falters, Bechet jumps right
in and takes over the melody. This shifting back and forth by Bechet between
the melody and the harmony (atong with Bunk's erratic playing) leads to
constant conflicts; sometimes both horns briefly state the melody, sometimes
neither! The battle between their different approaches (Bechet is hyper
and forceful while Bunk is laid-back) is intriguing but it is obvious
why this situation could not last for long. Bechet sometimes plays as
if Johnson were not even on stage. (Total Time: 59:44) AMG *** Review - U. S. Jazz Guide In the spring of 1945, soprano saxophonist Sidney Bechet attempted to
co-lead a New Orleans jazz band with veteran trumpeter Bunk Johnson, but
before their residency at Boston's Savoy Café was half completed,
Bunk had drunk himself out of the band. Bechet then sent to New Orleans
for his old associate Peter Bocage, but Bocage only lasted a month. The
trumpeter's playing was too gentle and laid-back, and he was also a little
past his prime. This CD, which has selections from three radio broadcasts,
generally find Bechet overpowering Bocage. It quickly becomes apparent
that the music would be better if the soprano great were simply being
featured in a quartet without trumpet. There are some good moments along
the way (particularly from Bechet) on such numbers as "After You've
Gone," "Oh Lady Be Good," and "The World Is Waiting
for the Sunrise," but these performances are mostly of historic interest.
|
|